The international board set up by President Trump to oversee the Gaza ceasefire says the truce is at risk, and it puts part of the blame on both Israel and Hamas. The Board of Peace's 12-page report to the United Nations Security Council was seen by Reuters and reported on Wednesday, November 18.
"A ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely," the report says.
The main warning
The ceasefire took effect in October 2025, about 13 months ago. It has stopped the large-scale fighting. But the bigger plan behind it has largely stalled, according to the report. That plan calls for Hamas to give up its weapons, for Israeli troops to pull back, and for rebuilding to begin.
The report says "the distance between what has been agreed and what is happening on the ground" is the biggest risk to the whole process.
Reuters published excerpts, not the full report, so some of its details and recommendations may not be public yet. It's the board's second report to the Security Council. The board is expected to present its findings in New York at the end of November.
What the report says about Israel
- Israel has carried out near-daily strikes on Gaza, which the report says has delayed testing whether Hamas will follow through on its promises.
- It faults Israel's government for an "absence of decisions" on training and deploying a civilian Palestinian police force meant to replace Hamas's control of security. Without that force, the report says, the plan can't move forward.
- Limits on supplies and equipment, together with funding shortfalls, held back preparations for winter flooding.
Israel rejected a board roadmap earlier this year. Its position is that troops won't withdraw until Hamas is dismantled. Defence Minister Israel Katz repeated that on Wednesday, saying Israeli forces will stay until Hamas is gone and Gaza is disarmed. That comment wasn't a direct answer to the report.
What the report says about Hamas
- Hamas agreed in July to a board roadmap to hand over its weapons and give control of Gaza to a civilian transitional authority.
- But its fighters have kept attacking Israeli troops, the report says.
- Hamas is collecting taxes on goods coming into Gaza, which the report says is hurting the supply of basic goods.
Responses
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office and a spokesperson for Hamas's political office didn't immediately respond to Reuters' requests for comment.
Life in Gaza now
More than 2 million Palestinians live on about a third of Gaza's land, mostly in tents and damaged buildings, according to Reuters. Israel holds the other two-thirds. Heavy rain flooded camps for displaced people last week, and more rain is expected this month. The report says the population "faces another winter in tents and rubble."
The numbers on both sides are heavy. About 1,200 people were killed in Israel in the Hamas-led attack on October 7, 2023. Gaza's Health Ministry says more than 74,000 Palestinians have been killed in the war since then; Israel disputes how that figure is counted and says it doesn't separate fighters from civilians. Since the ceasefire began, more than 1,600 Palestinians and five Israeli soldiers have been killed in Gaza, Reuters reported.
What the board is
The Board of Peace was created as part of Trump's plan to end the Gaza war, and Trump heads it. Its job is to oversee the ceasefire, the handover of security and the start of reconstruction. Its reports go to the UN Security Council, which backed the plan.
Why it matters
A collapse of the ceasefire would mean a return to full-scale war in Gaza, with civilians again paying the highest price. It would also add to tensions across a region already shaken by the U.S.-Iran war and attacks on shipping in the Gulf.
The report's message to both sides is simple: the truce has bought time, but time alone won't hold it together. Something on the ground has to change, from a working police force to rebuilding and real steps on disarmament.
What to watch
- The board's presentation to the Security Council in New York at the end of November.
- Any formal response from Israel's government or Hamas.
- Whether the civilian police force finally gets approved and trained.
Sources
- Reuters (via Cyprus Mail): Trump's Board of Peace faults Israel and Hamas for failure to end Gaza war (Nov. 18, 2026) cyprus-mail.com
- Reuters (via Al-Monitor): Trump's Board of Peace faults Israel and Hamas al-monitor.com
- Ynet: Trump's Board of Peace warns Gaza ceasefire could collapse ynetnews.com
