We may earn a commission from Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Common Sense Desk earns from qualifying purchases.
A federal jury in Los Angeles found Jonathan Rinderknecht guilty on Friday, November 20, of starting the fire that grew into the deadly Palisades Fire of January 2025. It was the government's second try. His first trial ended in a mistrial in June when the jury couldn't agree.
The jury reached its verdict on both counts in the retrial at about 2:45 p.m. local time, NBC Los Angeles reported. Rinderknecht showed no visible reaction when it was read. Sentencing is set for March 17, 2027.
What he was convicted of
Prosecutors say Rinderknecht set a small fire just after midnight on New Year's Day 2025 near the Skull Rock trailhead in Topanga State Park, above Pacific Palisades. Firefighters put out that blaze, known as the Lachman Fire. Prosecutors argued it kept burning underground in the roots and brush, then flared back up six days later in strong winds on January 7 and became the Palisades Fire.
The retrial had two federal arson counts: destruction of property by means of fire, and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce, ABC News reported. The jury convicted him on both. Prosecutors dropped a third charge from the first trial, timber set afire.
The Palisades Fire killed 12 people, burned more than 23,000 acres and destroyed thousands of homes and other buildings. Prosecutors put the damage at about $25 billion.
Bill Essayli, the First Assistant U.S. Attorney in Los Angeles, spoke after the verdict. "The question at the time was who is responsible," he said, according to ABC News. "And now we have the answer to that question."
How the case was built
Nobody saw the fire start and no camera caught the moment it was lit. So the case rested on putting a lot of smaller pieces together. "Piece it together. Look at it as a whole," prosecutor Danbee Kim told jurors in closing, NBC Los Angeles reported.
Prosecutors said Rinderknecht, a former Uber driver who lived in the area, was angry and alone that New Year's Eve. Several of his Uber passengers that night remembered him being upset, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office. They also pointed to:
- Cellphone location data that prosecutors said placed him close to where the Lachman Fire began, and near it as it grew.
- Surveillance video of his car driving through Pacific Palisades before the fire.
- Attempts to call 911 around the time of the fire, including a screen recording.
- A barbecue lighter found in his car.
- Searches he made afterward asking whether a fire could be started by accident with a cigarette.
- Statements to investigators about where he was that prosecutors said weren't true.
The defense, led by attorney Steve Haney, argued the case was circumstantial. Haney told jurors there was no physical evidence showing Rinderknecht used a lighter, that dozens of lighter tests didn't show the kind of fire spread prosecutors described, and that New Year's fireworks could have started the Lachman Fire. He also questioned whether embers really survived six days and reignited. Rinderknecht pleaded not guilty.
His father, Joel Rinderknecht, said he still believes his son is innocent and called the verdict a miscarriage of justice, NBC Los Angeles reported.
Why there was a second trial
The first trial ended in June with a hung jury. Jurors told U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang they were deadlocked on all three counts, with 10 of 12 leaning toward acquittal, according to media reports at the time. Prosecutors said right away they would try him again.
This time the jury deliberated over about two to three days after closing arguments on Tuesday. One juror told FOX 11 Los Angeles he had at first been a holdout. "What I will say is that his intent was to start a fire," the juror said. "What that fire did after his actions... led to January 7th."
What people in Los Angeles said
Mayor Karen Bass said in a statement that "no verdict can bring back the lives lost" and that "Los Angeles will always stand with Pacific Palisades." City Councilmember Traci Park, who represents the area, said, "It's not full accountability. There is still a lot more for us to do."
The Los Angeles Fire Department said it respects the jury's work but would not comment further "because the criminal sentencing and related civil matters remain pending."
Park's comment reflects a wider debate in the city. Many residents have asked why the Lachman Fire wasn't fully put out the first time, and how the city prepared for the windstorm that followed. Those questions are separate from Rinderknecht's guilt, and this verdict doesn't answer them.
What it means
For the families of the 12 people who died, and for the thousands who lost homes, the verdict gives a legal answer to the question of how the fire started. It doesn't rebuild anything.
The prison term won't be known until March. Reports differ on the maximum sentence he faces, and we'll add the exact figure once the Justice Department confirms it.
The fire department's mention of "related civil matters" is a reminder that the money side is still playing out separately. A criminal conviction doesn't by itself decide who pays for the damage, and those questions move through civil courts and insurance claims on their own timeline.
For anyone living near brush and canyons, the case is a hard lesson that a fire can look out and still be alive underground. Fire officials have long advised keeping a clear space around homes, having a go-bag ready, and signing up for local emergency alerts. A ready-made emergency go-bag and a home fire extinguisher are simple things to have on hand. For background, Timothy Egan's The Big Burn tells the story of the 1910 fire that shaped how America fights wildfires.
What's next
Sentencing is scheduled for March 17, 2027. The defense can appeal. We'll add a dated update when the sentence is handed down or the Justice Department releases its figures.
Sources
- ABC News: Man accused of starting blaze that became Palisades Fire found guilty of arson in retrial (Nov. 20, 2026) abcnews.com
- NBC Los Angeles: Man found guilty of starting Palisades Fire in federal prosecutors' second attempt (Nov. 20, 2026) nbclosangeles.com
- FOX 11 Los Angeles: Palisades Fire retrial verdict, Jonathan Rinderknecht (Nov. 20, 2026) foxla.com
- TheWrap (via Yahoo): Palisades Fire Suspect Jonathan Rinderknecht Found Guilty of Starting Deadly Blaze After Retrial (Nov. 20, 2026) yahoo.com
